This is a editorial originally written to be published in the Southern Accent newspaper. The paper chose not to publish it, so I've placed it here.


Quit Blaming Me
by Geof Greenway

In his March 25 article titled "Black and Proud" on Salon.com, writer Michael Finley says:

"There must be something wrong with me, because when I got my census form last week, I dutifully filled it out. That is, until I came to the section on race. On an impulse, I said that our entire family was black. We aren't. One look in the mirror confirms that. We are white as sheets, off-white sheets anyway, all four of us."

He goes on to say that five reasons contributed to his decision to mark himself as black. 1. The question bugs him, as he wonders what it says about himself when he says that he's black. 2. The census is for apportioning accurate congressional districts, and race shouldn't matter. 3. He always wanted to be black. 4. He thought it would be good for his family, and told them so at supper that night. 5. He wanted to show solidarity with his diverse extended family.

I haven't even received a census form, but I might like to choose the option that Mr. Finley did, but for quite a different reason. Here we are at the end of March. White folks have had almost a month to recover from "Black History Month." Recover? Let me explain.

I'm big on diversity. I think it is reflected by the music I listen to, the churches I attend, and the people I call friends. But something always starts to irk me, come February 1: it's now open season on whites. We are treated to a full month of "inspirational" speakers who drive home again and again that "you whites did a terrible, terrible thing when you enslaved us blacks." Yes, the message may be veiled underneath a call to greater "diversity," but the barbs are still well-placed, and evenly spaced. Excuse me?

For the record, I'm very, very sorry that SOME white plantation owners, especially here in the South, enslaved SOME African Americans. But, then again, I'm sorry about a lot of things, the Holocaust, the flood waters in Mozambique, and the fact that the whole world hasn't yet heard about Jesus Christ. But, my being sorry does nothing for anyone. Some would even argue that I have no business even being sorry for things that I cannot take credit for.

The difference here is that I get the blame for slavery. Every February I get blamed. I get told that had not MY ancestors been cruel and unusual, blacks would be better off today. I get told that I'M responsible for allowing the wall of segration to continue to exist. But I don't buy that, either.

A quick search among the branches of my family tree suggests that no, MY ancestors weren't plantation owners, let alone slave owners. In fact, a quick search among MANY white folks family trees would attest to the same facts. Likewise, a look along many black family trees would clear the air concerning their "ancestors" who were "burdened unmercilessly" under the "cruel hands of the white man." In many cases, these ancestors wouldn't exist.

The irony of the situation is the bandwagon effect. Because I'm white, I'm thrown onto the wagon of slave-buying plantation owners. And many blacks jump on the wagon of freedom-starved slaves. Now, don't get me wrong. I'm not suggesting that slaves and their cruel owners didn't exist. I'm suggesting that the percentage of people with true ancestors who were slaves or slave owners is likely quite small.

It's all history. Trying to create fresh wounds in the minds of black listeners during speeches during Black History Month does nothing to encourage diversity. Adding a heaping tablespoon of guilt on white listeners does even less to encourage diversity.

Instead, let's stand together, as one people, as children of God, not pointing the finger, not passing the guilt, not passing the blame. Let's learn about, and from one another. Let's spend some time getting to know other cultures, other races, and other traditions. Please, call me up and ask to go with me to Chattanooga's "black" church next Sabbath. Or Korean. Or Spanish. Or head with me down to Oakwood College for a weekend of great music, fun, and fellowship. Take a trip to Oregon with me to visit my El Salvadoran brother-in-law. Or, join with me during Black History Month in studying up on black people in history who the history books may have brushed over.

And, stop blaming me for something I didn't do to you, and my ancestors didn't do to your ancestors.


©2000 by Geof Greenway.

For thoughts and opinions, please email to editorials@geofgreenway.com. For usage rights, inquiries into my writing, or getting me to write something for you, contact me using one of the methods found on the Contact Information pages.